HERALD

Chikomba RDC’s six-year legal battle with workers over US$2.50 ends in humiliating defeat

Fidelis Munyoro

Chief Court Reporter

Chikomba Rural District Council has suffered yet another bruising courtroom defeat in its relentless battle against three former employees fired in September 2020 following an internal disciplinary hearing over alleged cash discrepancies involving a claimed prejudice of ZWL$50 (about US$2.50 at the time).

The former employees Lawrence Magwiroto, Rosa Chikwama and Martha Mudzana keep beating council in court as judge tells defiant local authority that it was not for the litigants to choose which decision to comply with.

The ZWL$50 dispute, worth approximately US$2.50 at the time, has spiralled into a six-year legal nightmare for Chikomba Rural District Council.

In what amounts to another stinging judicial rebuke, the Labour Court has effectively told the council that it cannot keep challenging decisions it has lost while refusing to obey the very orders flowing from those defeats.

The latest setback came after Justice Motion Jaravani ruled that Chikomba RDC must first comply with previous orders to reinstate Magwiroto, Chikwama and Mudzana before it can be heard on its latest appeal.

The judge’s words were particularly damning.

“It is not for the litigants to choose which decision to comply with or to defy,” Justice Jaravani declared, in a passage that captures the heart of the council’s mounting legal troubles.

The dispute dates back to disciplinary proceedings in which the three employees were dismissed over allegations of misconduct involving council revenue.

Magwiroto’s case involved an alleged ZWL$50 discrepancy, a paltry amount by any measure, but what followed would turn into an extraordinary legal marathon, with the council repeatedly finding itself on the losing side of the courtroom battle.

The employees refused to accept their dismissals and took their fight to the National Employment Council Exemptions Committee (ExCom).

In March 2021, ExCom overturned the disciplinary verdicts and ordered the council to reinstate all three employees without loss of salaries and benefits.

But instead of implementing the decisions, Chikomba RDC went on the offensive.

It appealed against the ExCom determinations at the Labour Court, only to suffer another series of humiliating defeats. Its appeals were dismissed between February and October 2024, leaving the reinstatement orders intact.

Yet the council still did not reinstate the workers.

That failure would eventually come back to haunt it.

The three former employees subsequently pursued outstanding salaries, benefits and union dues, leading to an arbitral award in their favour covering the period from January 2019 to August 2025.

Rather than settle the claims, the council launched another appeal, bringing the parties back before the Labour Court.

But this time, the employees had a powerful preliminary argument: why should a court entertain a litigant that had repeatedly ignored decisions made against it?

They invoked the dirty hands doctrine, arguing that the council should not be allowed to seek further judicial relief while remaining in defiance of existing orders.

Justice Jaravani agreed.

The judge found that the ExCom decisions and subsequent Labour Court judgments remained binding and enforceable. The council could not simply disregard them because it disagreed with their consequences.

In a further blow, the court rejected the council’s argument that the reinstatement decisions were not binding because they did not provide for damages in lieu of reinstatement.

Justice Jaravani pointed out that the council had an opportunity to challenge the decisions on that basis during its previous appeals but had failed to do so.

The judge was equally unequivocal about the consequences of the council’s conduct.

“The dirty hands rule prohibits courts from countenancing litigants’ defiance of the law by granting them audience despite their non-compliance with the law,” the judgment states.

The court found that the council’s failure to comply with the reinstatement orders constituted an unfair labour practice under section 8(e)(ii) and (iv) of the Labour Act.

It said the council should either reinstate the former employees or invoke legally recognised procedures to demonstrate that reinstatement was no longer tenable and offer damages in lieu.

In the end, the employees secured another significant victory.

The court upheld their dirty-hands objection and removed the council’s appeal from the roll pending compliance with the outstanding reinstatement orders. Each party was ordered to bear its own costs.

The distinction is important in that the court did not determine the merits of the latest monetary award. Rather, it made clear that the council cannot proceed with its appeal until it complies with the earlier orders.

For Magwiroto, Chikwama and Mudzana, the latest ruling is another chapter in a long fight for justice and the employment rights recognised in their favour.

For Chikomba RDC, however, the legal battle has become an increasingly uncomfortable lesson in the consequences of ignoring binding decisions.

A dispute involving just ZWL$50 has now generated years of litigation, repeated courtroom defeats and a judicial warning that no litigant, however powerful, can pick and choose which court orders to obey.

Six years later, three former employees are still fighting and Chikomba RDC is still being told to go back and do what the courts ordered.