Rutendo Nyeve
FOG and low cloud conditions preceded the helicopter crash that killed prominent businessman Wicknell Chivhayo, his wife Lucy “Lulu” Muteke-Chivayo and three others in Marondera, according to a preliminary investigation report released by Government.
The report says the Bell 430 helicopter, registration Z-PED, continued flying after a second aircraft in its formation diverted when weather conditions deteriorated during the flight on September 30.
The helicopter, operated by Sky Helicopters Company (Pvt) Ltd, crashed at Kudenga Farm, about 22 kilometres south-west of Marondera in Mashonaland East Province, while on a private flight from Gandami Village.
According to the report by the Ministry of Transport and Infrastructural Development, the Bell 430 was flying in formation with a Bell 407, registration Z-OSM, under visual flight rules when a low-level cloud layer approached from the east.
“The flight was uneventful until approximately ten minutes after departure, when a low-level cloud layer was reported approaching from the east,” reads the report.
While the Bell 407 diverted west, Z-PED continued north-east. Its last radio transmission indicated that it had entered another layer of cloud and had not yet emerged.
Witnesses at Kudenga Farm said they heard a helicopter overhead for about 10 minutes but could not see it because of drizzle and dense fog.
“They then heard a loud impact, followed by silence,” reads the report.
Investigators have classified the accident under two categories — Unintended Flight into Instrument Meteorological Conditions (UIMC) and Controlled Flight into or Toward Terrain (CFIT).
The report also notes that the Meteorological Services Department had issued a severe weather advisory for the period, warning of widespread thunderstorms, lightning and strong wind gusts, with cloud ceilings expected to be as low as 1 500 to 2 000 feet.
The helicopter was destroyed by the impact and a fire that broke out after the crash.
“The airframe disintegrated into numerous fragments and the wreckage field measured 170 metres long and 75 metres wide. Distribution of key wreckage components confirms the aircraft remained intact until impact. There is no evidence of an in-flight breakup or pre-impact explosion,” reads the report.
The accident was classified as non-survivable because of the magnitude of the deceleration forces and the severity of the post-impact fire.
The pilot, aged 44, held a Commercial Pilot Licence (Helicopter) and had accumulated 2 756 flying hours, including 614 hours on the Bell 430.
His medical certificate was valid and investigators found no previous occurrences involving the crew.
The aircraft had accumulated 1 831.2 airframe hours and held a valid Certificate of Airworthiness.
It was also equipped with a serviceable dual auto-flight system, Ground Proximity Warning System and Automatic Emergency Locator Transmitter.
However, the Cockpit Voice Recorder was not recovered and is presumed to have been destroyed in the crash.
The report further notes that neither the departure point nor the intended destination had an aerodrome, meaning standard aerodrome facilities were unavailable.
Investigations are continuing, with the wreckage having been moved to a secure facility. Initial interviews have also been conducted with the crew of the accompanying Bell 407, eyewitnesses and first responders.
“Further analysis and investigation are necessary to determine the probable cause(s) and contributing factors, with a final report to follow,” reads the report.