CHRONICLE

Council stands firm on lucrative TENDY Three Investments parking model

Sikhulekelani Moyo, [email protected]

TENDY Three Investments (TTI) is not a separate entity but a special business unit of the Bulawayo City Council, operated under the Public-Private Partnership (PPP) policy to cut labour costs, Town Clerk Mr Christopher Dube has said.

He was speaking during an engagement between the local authority and the Bulawayo business community on Friday on the city’s 2027 budget.

Mr Dube said council deliberately stopped collecting parking fees directly because of what he termed structural labour issues.

Tendy Three Investments (TTI) parking marshalls and (INSET) Town Clerk Mr Christopher Dube

“We are following a Government policy of triple Ps [Public-Private Partnerships]. I can tell you why we stopped collecting ourselves as council, because of unionisation, our unionised labour force,” said Mr Dube.

He said if council were to take over parking management today with the same staff complement, it would not even realise the 30 percent it is currently getting.

“If we were to remove TTI today and put our parking management in similar numbers, we will obviously not get the 30 percent that we are getting from TTI now. We will lose all the money to labour. So, that is the reason why we decided that we privatised that thing,” he added.

“Under the six-year Build-Operate-Transfer contract which ends in December 2027, TTI retains 70 percent of revenue and remits 30 percent to council.”

Mr Dube said council incurs no costs, saying: “TTI is part of Bulawayo City Council. Point fingers at Bulawayo City Council if things are not going well; don’t mention TTI. We can change the name, but it remains a city council special business unit.

“We have a contract with TTI for six years; after that we can take over. Even if we take over and it is 100 percent controlled by the City of Bulawayo, we don’t even plan to make that a department.

It will remain operating like that, as a special business unit, with its rights and with its structure, privately, to avoid the salaries. In any business, which business can get a 30 percent net profit? We are making a net profit of 30 cents per dollar. Whatever TTI collects, 30 cents is ours. We have no costs; we are only collecting money.”

Mr Dube said councillors who once demanded the removal of TTI changed their minds after seeing the figures.

“When people were making a lot of noise, and even our councillors did not understand, they threw it back to us. Even the Mayor himself, when he came, was campaigning for the removal of TTI, and when he came in and realised how much TTI, small as it is, is bringing in revenue better than even the Zimbabwe National Road Authority.”

On complaints of heavy-handed enforcement, Mr Dube admitted there were challenges, saying there were pertinent issues raised by residents to the effect that marshals are at times heavy-handed.

He said enforcement is not child’s play, and given the confusion that was in the city, they needed it to begin with.

“We needed to make a statement, and we made a statement,” he said.

He said marshals found to be heavy-handed have been disciplined and some removed from their posts.

“So, it’s not TTI, it’s the City of Bulawayo that we are talking about. We are talking to ourselves; tell us to do better. If TTI, as an acronym, is actually hurting people, we can change that acronym and call it BCC, so that it will remain operating the same.”

Responding to a question on whether TTI pays less than the council Grade 4 scale, Mr Dube said: “Yes, by far. And that is not illegal, because TTI is operating as a company, and we stopped doing that ourselves as a council, because with our structures, the parking assistant being in Grade 4 and getting that much, we were no longer making money; we were making a loss on parking management.”

He likened the model to Ingwebu Breweries, which was also pushed to operate as a separate commercial entity.

Council says the 2027 budget consultations will continue to address residents’ concerns while maintaining the PPP model.

The City of Bulawayo entered into a six-year partnership with TTI to improve city parking and maintain order in the city.

The Town Clerk emphasised that the main agenda was to maintain order, not necessarily to make money out of the partnership, which he however said has been helping the local authority cut expenditure and improve revenue.