Fidelis Munyoro
Chief Court Reporter
A High Court judge has called for certainty in land rights, warning that citizens who follow due process in acquiring agricultural land should not be left uncertain about their tenure, as competing claims over farms continue to generate litigation.
“There is a need for certainty in land rights and no citizen should suffer anxiety regarding tenure where they have followed due process where land allocation is concerned,” Justice Munangati-Manongwa said.
The judge made the remarks while dismissing an application by Ruth Gwashavanhu seeking to evict 11 people from Subdivision 1 of Fairview Estate in Goromonzi, Mashonaland East, in a dispute that brought competing land allocations under the A1 and A2 resettlement models before the court.
The case exposes the difficulties arising when land allocated to beneficiaries under different phases of the land reform programme overlaps, leaving occupants and subsequent beneficiaries contesting their rights to the same property.
Gwashavanhu sought the eviction of Innocent Katiyo, Joel Mazarura, Kazingizi Sheddy, Tichaona Nyamakura, Matibvu Upenyu, Gilbert Katokwe, Andrew Mushamba, Daniel Tsiga, Esau Kanyonga, Gorge Karimanzira and Tendai Chikoto from the 237.8548-hectare property.
She argued that she was the lawful holder and occupier through an A2 Model Settlement Permit issued by the Ministry of Lands, followed by an Agreement of Sale covering the same property.
The A2 Model Settlement Scheme is a key component of the country’s land reform programme, intended to create a class of indigenous commercial farmers with access to land on which they can undertake agricultural production.
Its economic role is linked to the country’s efforts to increase food production, generate agricultural exports, create employment, support agro-processing and strengthen rural incomes.
A2 beneficiaries are expected to use their allocated farms as productive commercial enterprises, contributing to national food security and the agricultural value chain.
Land tenure certainty is, therefore, central to the model.
Farmers need confidence that their allocation will be respected to enable them to invest in infrastructure, irrigation, equipment, livestock and other productive assets without facing competing claims to the land.
The dispute centred on a 237.8548-hectare farm and the question of whether Gwashavanhu’s A2 allocation displaced claims by beneficiaries who said they had occupied portions of the estate for years.
The respondents argued that their allocations predated her permit and that their occupation had previously been protected by court orders. They relied on allocation documents, correspondence from land administration officials, payment receipts and evidence of occupation.
They also cited a 2004 consent order granted by Justice Ben Hlatshwayo, which allowed beneficiaries to remain on Oribi Farm, Fairview Farm, Kilmur Farm and Melrose Farm until they were properly settled by the Government or evicted by an order of a competent court.
Gwashavanhu maintained that the respondents had no current legal instruments authorising their occupation.
But Justice Munangati-Manongwa said the existence of her permit did not automatically establish an entitlement to evict the occupants.
“The validity of an instrument must be distinguished from its scope and application to the disputed land,” she said.
The judge identified four disputes requiring determination: the identity and boundaries of the property, the origin and scope of Gwashavanhu’s allocation, the respondents’ earlier allocations and the effect of previous court orders.
She said resolving the issues would require evidence from Ministry of Lands officials, allocation records and earlier court proceedings.
“This is not a case of a lawful occupier removing a recent trespasser but one of competing beneficiaries whose claims derive from different stages of land reform,” she said.
The court also noted that a November 2025 consent order had directed the parties to remain on the portions they physically occupied pending resolution of the dispute.
The judge said neither long occupation nor possession of a later permit conclusively settled the competing claims.
Zimbabwe’s National Development Strategy 2 recognises tenure security as a requirement for agricultural investment, identifying title deeds as a means of restoring farmers’ confidence to invest in infrastructure and increasing productivity.
The strategy also links consolidation of fragmented holdings to mechanisation and access to structured markets.
The Land Commission Act recognises permits, offer letters and leases as instruments conferring lawful occupation rights over State agricultural land.
Justice Munangati-Manongwa stressed that her ruling did not invalidate Gwashavanhu’s A2 permit or establish that the respondents held superior or permanent rights to the land.
She dismissed the eviction application and ordered Gwashavanhu to pay costs on the ordinary scale to the first, second, fourth, fifth, tenth and eleventh respondents.
The Commissioner of Police and the Minister of Lands, Agriculture and Water Settlement were cited in the proceedings, with the police commissioner indicating that he would abide by the court’s decision.
The ruling leaves the competing claims unresolved, with the judge indicating that their determination requires proceedings capable of receiving oral and documentary evidence.