The Miss South Africa Organisation has responded to the backlash following the crowning of Tiyani Makamu as Miss South Africa 2026 on Saturday after viewers expressed disappointment over the appearance of her crown.
The gold-coloured headpiece quickly became a talking point on social media, with some viewers comparing it to a fast-food restaurant crown while others described it as “homemade”.
Actress Jessica Nkosi also took to Instagram to express her disappointment, calling on the organisation to apologise to Tiyani and give her a proper crowning.
“You not getting it!!!! You need to apologize to Tiyani. You owe her an apology and a proper crowning. To put a paper crown on her with a shoelace at the back?!?!?! Please!!!!!!! Stop it! This was supposed to be monumental for her but you let her down!!”
Jessica further praised Tiyani, saying she was beautiful and smart and would represent South Africa well.
South Africans also questioned the decision to proceed with the ceremony without the official crown.
On X, @_GeeWrites criticised the organisation, saying: “Why did we go ahead with the ceremony without the official crown? This is unacceptable colleagues, you failed Tiyani and in fact you have put her under unnecessary scrutiny because she also seemed unhappy about it!! This was not fair on her and the work she put into this journey!”
Meanwhile, @Essie75271087 questioned whether the contestants had been informed about the arrangement beforehand.
“Yes, it’s not only about beauty, glits and glamour but on the night THAT crown is what seals the evening. They robbed her of her MOMENT.”
Responding to the criticism, the Miss South Africa Organisation released a statement acknowledging the public disappointment and explaining that the crown presented during the finale was temporary.
“Regarding the crown presented during the finale, we wish to clarify that it was a temporary ceremonial crown, while preparations for the official Miss South Africa crown are being finalised.”
The organisation further explained that its intention was to allow South Africans to participate in the journey towards unveiling the official crown, which it believes should reflect the collective identity and aspirations of the nation.
However, it admitted that the decision should have been communicated more clearly before the finale.
“We acknowledge that this intention should have been communicated more clearly ahead of the finale. While we stand by the vision behind this decision, we accept that the lack of context created unnecessary uncertainty.”
The organisation also addressed questions surrounding the judging process, maintaining that the competition looks beyond physical beauty and considers qualities such as intelligence, leadership, authenticity, compassion and communication skills.
It further confirmed that the judging process was conducted independently and in accordance with the established criteria.
Despite the criticism surrounding the crowning, the organisation expressed its support for Tiyani, emphasising that she deserves to begin her reign with dignity and encouragement.
“We stand firmly behind our newly crowned Miss South Africa, Tiyani, and the qualities that earned her this honour.”
The organisation concluded by acknowledging the importance of public opinion and reaffirming its commitment to listening to South Africans.
“Miss South Africa is a national institution, and the voices of South Africans will always matter.” –OK