Fidelis Munyoro
Chief Court Reporter
The Mining Industry Pension Fund (MIPF) has won its legal battle against Perce (Private) Limited after the High Court dismissed an application seeking to overturn an arbitral award that valued the fund’s 48 percent shareholding in New Corporate Investments (Seven) (Private) Limited at US$2,97 million.
In a judgment by Justice Lucy Mungwari, the court also granted MIPF’s application to have the arbitral award recognised and registered as an order of the High Court, paving the way for its enforcement against Perce.
The dispute arose from a 1995 shareholders’ agreement involving Perce, MIPF and defunct Standard Chartered Bank Zimbabwe Limited, which led to the formation of NewCo as a vehicle to hold the property on which Flamboyant Hotel in Masvingo operates.
Perce had borrowed money from MIPF and Standard Chartered Bank to acquire the property but fell into default. Under the restructuring agreement, ownership of the hotel property was transferred to NewCo, while Perce remained in occupation as a tenant and was required to pay rentals.
The agreement provided for Perce to acquire the shares held by MIPF and Standard Chartered Bank once the shareholder loans had been repaid.
However, the parties failed to agree on the purchase price, resulting in litigation and a consent order in June 2022 referring the dispute to arbitration.
The arbitrator, Mr Godknows Hofisi, handed down his award on August 8, 2025, valuing MIPF’s 48 percent shareholding at US$2 970 958,51. He also calculated rental arrears owed by Perce to NewCo at US$3 723 574,18 for the period between 2009 and June 2025.
Perce approached the High Court seeking to set aside the award, arguing that the arbitrator had exceeded his mandate by determining rental obligations arising from a lease between Perce and NewCo, rather than MIPF.
It also argued that the arbitrator had improperly incorporated the rental arrears into NewCo’s net asset value, thereby affecting the share purchase price.
However, Justice Mungwari ruled that the arbitrator had acted within the terms of the consent order, which required him to determine the share price, any dividend arising from rentals and the rentals payable.
“The rental determination is the input to the dividend enquiry, not its product,” said Justice Mungwari.
The judge held that the arbitrator was required to establish the rentals before determining whether any dividend was payable.
Justice Mungwari also rejected Perce’s argument that MIPF was seeking to enforce contractual rights under an agreement to which it was not a party.
The court found that the arbitrator had not ordered Perce to pay rentals to MIPF but had treated the outstanding rentals as an asset belonging to NewCo when calculating the company’s net asset value.
“Privity of contract governs who may enforce a contract. It does not stop a valuer from recognising that a company has a claim against a third party when valuing that company,” the judge said.
The court further found that NewCo had been cited in the arbitration proceedings but had not participated.
On the question of prescription, Justice Mungwari held that Perce had failed to discharge the burden of proving that the rental claims had prescribed. The judge noted that Perce had not called any of its officers or employees to testify before the arbitrator.
The court also dismissed MIPF’s preliminary argument that Perce had forfeited its right to challenge the award by engaging in discussions about payment after the arbitration.
Justice Mungwari found that the discussions did not amount to unequivocal acceptance of the award and that Perce had filed its challenge within the three-month period provided for under the Arbitration Act.
The judge said courts must exercise restraint when dealing with applications to set aside arbitral awards, as arbitration is intended to bring disputes to an end.
“An award will not be contrary to public policy merely because the reasoning or conclusions of the arbitrator are wrong in fact or in law,” Justice Mungwari said, citing the Supreme Court judgment in Zimbabwe Electricity Supply Authority vs Maposa.
The court ordered that Perce’s application to set aside the award be dismissed and granted MIPF’s application for recognition and registration. Perce was also ordered to pay MIPF’s legal costs on the ordinary scale.