Ronald Mpofu
A WOMAN whose nearly 20-year marriage has been rocked by a DNA test revealing that her husband is not the biological father of their eldest child has responded to divorce proceedings by demanding half of their family home in Gweru.
Kumbirai Makore (née Muchena) is contesting her husband Aaron Makore’s proposed 80/ 20 division of their matrimonial property, insisting that an equal 50 /50 split would be fair and equitable.
The couple’s divorce dispute is unfolding at the Bulawayo High Court, where Mr Makore is seeking to end their marriage on the grounds of irretrievable breakdown.
The two married in an unregistered customary law union in 2006 before formalising their union through a civil marriage on November 14, 2014, under the then Marriages Act (Chapter 5:11).
Mr Makore, through his lawyer Mr Joshua Nembaware of T Hara and Partners, filed divorce summons on September 30, 2026.
In her response, Mrs Makore is challenging his proposal to take 80 percent of their family home, Stand Number 1559, Raylands, Gweru, arguing that she is entitled to an equal share.
She is also seeking an order for the property to be sold and the proceeds shared equally, with both parties contributing towards valuation costs.
The dispute extends to a rural homestead at Kuruneri Village in Gokwe North, under Chief
Nembudziya, where Mrs Makore is claiming an equal share of improvements made during the marriage.
Mr Makore disputes this, arguing that the homestead “was deserted long back and no one is staying there.”
However, beyond the battle over property, the divorce has exposed deep divisions over the circumstances that led to the collapse of the marriage, including the revelation that Mr Makore is allegedly not the biological father of the couple’s eldest child, identified in the court papers as Eric Richard Makore.
Mrs Makore says she was unaware of the child’s paternity and blames her husband’s alleged infidelity for the breakdown of their marriage.
She also denies infecting her husband with HIV, arguing that he was already taking medication when they entered into their customary union.
“The Defendant avers that she never infected the Plaintiff with HIV virus. The Plaintiff was already on HIV virus medication when they entered into unregistered customary law union,” she submitted.
Mrs Makore further disputes her husband’s claim that they had gone for more than a year without conjugal relations, saying they last had sex in May this year.
Mr Makore, however, maintains that his wife infected him with HIV and says his health has since deteriorated.
“The plaintiff does not have any strength or power since he is not well as the defendant infected him with the HIV virus. As such, he is always in and out of the hospital,” he stated.
On the paternity dispute, Mr Makore alleges that his wife had known for years that he was not the child’s biological father.
“The defendant was aware that the minor child, namely Erick Richard Makore, was not the Plaintiff’s biological son. The defendant even acknowledged this by stating that she had an affair with her sister’s husband. As a result of this affair, she bore this child,” he stated.
The couple are also at odds over maintenance for their minor children.
Mr Makore is offering US$30 or the ZiG equivalent per child, arguing that his self-employment and piece jobs bring him an average monthly income of US$150.
He says he cannot afford the US$50 per child sought by his wife while meeting his own expenses, including rent and food, but maintains that he will continue paying the children’s school fees.
The court is yet to determine the competing claims.