Tichawana Nyahuma
Yesterday, The Sunday Mail carried a story under the headline “If car is still in your name, tickets are yours”. It told of Enock Mushambi, who sold his car four years ago, never completed the change of ownership, and now receives traffic violation alerts from the Smart Traffic Management System (STMS) for offences committed by whoever is driving it today.
The story performs a public service in that it reminds motorists to regularise ownership at the Central Vehicle Registry (CVR).
The Vehicle Registration and Licensing Act (Chapter 13:14) places duties on both parties to a sale. Section 13 requires the seller to notify the Registrar of the disposal and section 14 requires the new owner to register the change.
A seller who ignores section 13 has defaulted on a registration duty and must answer for that under the registration statute.
That is a world apart from saying he jumped a red robot along Samora Machel Avenue last Tuesday. Offences under the Road Traffic Act (Chapter 13:11) are committed by drivers. Criminal liability in our law is personal.
The State must prove, beyond reasonable doubt, that the accused was the one who did the prohibited act. A registration book is evidence of who is recorded as owner. It is not evidence of who was behind the wheel.
Some jurisdictions have closed this gap by statute. South Africa’s Administrative Adjudication of Road Traffic Offences Act presumes that the owner was the driver but, even then, gives the owner a procedure to nominate the person actually driving.
Zimbabwe has no equivalent. Parliament has not enacted a presumption that the registered owner committed a driving offence and no ministerial statement, SMS or press interview can create one.
Our Road Traffic Act points the other way. Section 71 deals with the duty to give information relating to the identities of drivers.
The scheme is plain in that, where an offence is detected, the owner may be required to help identify the driver.
The law treats the owner as a source of information about the offender and not as the offender. That is the only sensible reading of Commissioner Paul Nyathi’s remark, quoted in the article, that “you remain accountable until change of ownership is effected”. Accountable to explain who had the car, yes. Guilty of what someone else did with it, no.
Consider Mr Mushambi’s position on the story’s own facts. The car has changed hands several times and he does not know who drives it. If every ticket is “his”, the person actually running red lights is never identified, never fined and never stopped.
A road-safety system that punishes the one person who certainly was not driving, while the real offender drives on, defeats its own purpose.
It also loads the burden on the wrong party. Of the four steps the article itself describes, only the first belongs to the seller: detaching the bottom section of the registration book and notifying CVR. Police clearance, ZIMRA’s special excise duty and registration are all the buyer’s steps.
The buyer’s failure under section 14 cannot be converted into the seller’s criminal record.
Where, then, does that leave a motorist in Mr Mushambi’s shoes? Under section 356 of the Criminal Procedure and Evidence Act (Chapter 9:07), paying a deposit fine is voluntary and is, in substance, an admission of guilt. An SMS is neither a summons nor a conviction. A motorist who did not commit the offence is entitled to dispute it and, if it comes to that, to be tried.
Nor is the seller left without an answer to the notification. An account that he was not driving, that he sold the vehicle and when, supported by the agreement of sale and the buyer’s particulars, is precisely the kind of information section 71 contemplates. It points the State to the driver where its attention belonged all along.
None of this excuses the paperwork. Notifying CVR of the disposal by affidavit if the agreement of sale has been lost, remains a statutory duty, and it is what ends the notifications.
But it is a registration duty. It is not an acceptance of someone else’s fines.
The authorities, too, have work to do. CVR and the ZRP should accept a seller’s notification, backed by a sale agreement or affidavit, as sufficient to flag the record and redirect notifications.
Parliament, whose Home Affairs committee has already called for the fines to be suspended, should legislate properly for camera enforcement creating a rebuttable owner presumption, a simple procedure to nominate the driver, and a cheap, independent appeal route.
Until then, the headline should be read in corrected form. If your car is still in your name, you have paperwork to do. The tickets belong to the driver.
This article expresses Tichawana Nyahuma’s personal opinion only and is not legal advice.
Feedback: [email protected]