CHRONICLE

Man loses appeal over US$45 000 property fraud

Danisa Masuku, Court Reporter

THE High Court has upheld a five-year prison sentence imposed on a 55-year-old man who forged an identity document to impersonate a property owner and attempted to sell a house for US$45 000.

Thembelani Masola had appealed against his conviction and sentence for forgery and fraud, arguing that the jail term was excessive and induced a sense of shock.

However, Bulawayo High Court judge Justice Munamato Mutevedzi, sitting with Justice Bongani Ndlovu, dismissed the appeal, ruling that the sentence imposed by the lower court was lenient given the seriousness of the offences.

“Fraud is a serious crime and the appellant intended to deprive the complainant of her house. He was supposed to be slapped with a heavy sentence,” he said.
Masola was convicted by a Bulawayo regional magistrate in August after forging a national identity card to falsely present himself as the owner of the property and attempting to sell it.

Through his lawyer, Mr Simbarashe Innocent Madzivire of Mashayamombe and Attorneys, Masola argued that the sentence should be set aside and the matter referred for community service assessment or that he be considered for a non-custodial sentence.

Mr Madzivire told the court that much of the property in question had been recovered and that his client had co-operated with detectives from the Commercial Crimes Division.

He also submitted that Masola was 55 years old, had previously lived a blameless life, had lost his job as a result of the case and had demonstrated remorse by apologising to the court.

“The appellant did not benefit from this crime and he prays that his appeal be upheld and the sentence of the court a quo be set aside,” he said.

The State opposed the appeal, arguing that the attempted fraud involved aggravating circumstances, including the use of forged documents and the intended sale of the property for US$45 000.
Chief Public Prosecutor Mr Kudakwashe Jaravaza represented the State.

Leave a Comment