Zimpapers Business Hub
THE High Court has upheld a multi-million-dollar arbitral award against Perce Limited, the operator of Masvingo’s Flamboyant Hotel, following a decades-long ownership and rental dispute with the Mining Industry Pension Fund (MIPF).
In a judgment delivered on November 11, 2026, the court dismissed Perce’s application to nullify the August 8, 2025 arbitral award issued by legal practitioner and chartered accountant Godknows Hofisi.
At the same time, the court granted MIPF’s cross-application to register the ruling as an enforceable court order under the Arbitration Act and ordered Perce—whose principal was the late politician and lawyer Eddison Zvobgo—to pay MIPF’s legal costs.
The legal battle traces back to 1991, when Perce borrowed money from MIPF and Standard Chartered Bank Zimbabwe to purchase the land for the Flamboyant Hotel.
After Perce defaulted on the loans, the three parties signed a Shareholders’ Agreement in February 1995 to restructure the debt.
Under the agreement, a special purpose vehicle named New Corporate Investments (NewCo) was created to hold the hotel property and assume the debt, with MIPF and Standard Chartered each taking a 48 percent stake and Perce holding 4 percent.
Perce leased back the hotel from NewCo, using its rent payments to service the loans. The deal gave Perce the option to buy out the two financiers based on NewCo’s net asset value once the debt was cleared.
Perce repaid the loans in the early 2000s and subsequently bought Standard Chartered’s 48 percent stake, becoming NewCo’s majority shareholder with 52 percent.
However, complications arose after Perce’s written lease expired on December 31, 2006.
While Perce remained in occupation of the hotel and paid 48 percent of the rent directly to MIPF for a few years, it stopped making payments entirely between 2009 and 2011.
When Perce eventually moved to exercise its option to buy out MIPF’s remaining 48 percent stake, the two sides could not agree on a valuation, prompting MIPF to sue in the High Court.
In June 2022, the parties agreed by consent order to refer the valuation and unpaid rent issues to arbitration. In his final award, Mr Hofisi ruled that a tacit lease had continued after 2006, meaning Perce was still legally obligated to pay rent.
Hofisi determined that Perce owed NewCo about US$3,7 million in unpaid rent up to June 30, 2025, with ongoing rent accruing at US$18 900 per month.
By factoring that unpaid rent directly into NewCo’s assets, Mr Hofisi valued the company at US$6,9 million, setting the buyout price for MIPF’s 48 percent shareholding at nearly US$3 million.
Perce challenged the award in the High Court, arguing that Mr Hofisi had exceeded his mandate.
The court rejected both claims, finding that the arbitrator stayed strictly within the terms of the 2022 consent order and that the financial outcome did not offend public policy or justice.
With the award now registered as a High Court order, Perce is legally required to pay MIPF nearly US$3 million to finalise the buyout of the pension fund’s shares.