CHRONICLE

Old Nic Mine robbery trial: Police evidence under scrutiny

Danisa Masuku, Court Reporter

GAPS in the police investigation into the US$790 000 Old Nic Mine armed robbery case emerged during trial proceedings, with a State witness admitting that statements were not recorded from most suspects at an identification parade and that there was no evidence linking seized cellphones to the accused persons.

The concessions came during cross-examination of police officer Jacob Chinyakata, who told the court that only one suspect’s statement had been recorded during the identification parade, despite eight suspects participating.

Chinyakata was testifying in the trial of Andile Mlilo, Thobekani Dlodlo, Content Mguni and Langathani Mlalazi, who are facing three counts of armed robbery arising from the June 2025 raid on Old Nic Mine on the outskirts of Bulawayo.

The quartet, who deny the charges, appeared before Bulawayo regional magistrate Mr Mark Dzira.

Mlilo, Dlodlo and Mlalazi are represented by Mr Goodluck Katenaire of Katenaire-Mbeure Law Chambers, while Mguni is represented by Mr Tinashe Dzipe of Morris-Davies Law Firm.
Chinyakata told the court that although eight suspects participated in the identification parade, he only recorded a statement from Mguni.

“There were eight suspects, including Mguni. I didn’t capture the statements of the other suspects. I only captured the statement of Mguni. That is why I don’t know Mlilo, Mlalazi and Dlodlo. I have never seen them,” he said.

The witness also told the court that police had seized cellphones and recovered audio recordings and WhatsApp messages, which were subsequently sent for forensic examination.

However, under cross-examination by Mr Katenaire, he conceded that police had not obtained a court order authorising the seizure of the phones and that there was no evidence establishing that the devices belonged to the four accused persons.

The circumstances surrounding the alleged recovery of stolen cash also came under scrutiny.

Chinyakata said police recovered US$2 150 hidden in a pit almost one metre deep, but admitted that the serial numbers of the recovered money had not been recorded in the seizure form.

Responding to questions from Mr Dzipe, he further conceded that the pit had neither been secured as a crime scene nor preserved as evidence.

The officer also told the court that police had observed newly acquired household property, including a refrigerator, bed and television, but admitted that there was no evidence linking the purchases to proceeds from the alleged robbery.

According to the State, the accused persons allegedly stole US$790 696,65 in cash and a mobile phone valued at US$130, bringing the total value of the stolen property to US$790 826,65.
Prosecuting, Mr Jethro Mada told the court that on June 23 last year, the accused allegedly connived to rob the gold mining enterprise after two of them, who were employees at the mine, obtained information about a substantial cash delivery.

“Mlilo and Dlodlo were employed at Old Nic Mine and caught wind of information that there was a massive cash delivery,” he said.

The State alleges that the two employees shared the information with their accomplices, who subsequently planned the robbery. Shortly before 1pm, Mguni, Mlalazi and two other suspects who are still at large allegedly descended on the mine armed with unidentified firearms and plastic cable ties.

The gang allegedly first subdued security guard Simon Gumbo, who was on duty at the car park.

The suspects allegedly threatened to shoot him, tied him with plastic cable ties and took his service firearm and communication radio before leaving one of their accomplices to guard him.

They then allegedly proceeded to the main offices, where they stole US$1 550.

Mr Mada told the court that the suspects subsequently entered the administration block, where they confronted accountant Kimberly Amy Fisher and her colleague, Kimberly Judith Muvidziwa.

“They pointed firearms at the two women and forced Fisher to open the financial safe, where they plundered US$769 016,65 in cash. They further ransacked the office and stole an additional US$20 000 housed inside a safe drawer,” he said.

Before fleeing, the suspects allegedly took Muvidziwa’s Redmi 13C cellphone, valued at US$130.

The State alleges that detectives later tracked down the suspects, leading to their arrest and the recovery of the cellphone and a small portion of the stolen cash.
The matter was postponed to December 8 for continuation of trial.

Leave a Comment