A South African woman whose business allegedly leaves her with approximately R109,000 a month after expenses has lost her bid to force her estranged husband, who takes home about R32,800 monthly, to pay her interim spousal maintenance and contribute R85,000 towards her legal costs.
The Western Cape High Court in Cape Town dismissed the woman’s Rule 43 application after finding that she had failed to properly disclose her financial position, particularly her average monthly earnings from her hair and make-up business.
The husband’s payslips showed that he earned an average gross monthly salary of R54,598.68, with his net salary averaging R32,838.63.
According to the husband, his wife’s business generated average monthly receipts of approximately R181,000, leaving her with about R109,800 after business expenses.
However, Judge DM Thulare noted that the woman had not disclosed under oath how much she earned on average each month. The judge found that the husband’s financial response raised genuine factual disputes and was supported by evidence.
Wife wanted R10,000 monthly spousal maintenance
The woman had approached the court seeking R12,000 monthly maintenance for the couple’s two minor children, R10,000 in monthly spousal maintenance and an R85,000 contribution towards her legal costs.
She also sought an order regulating primary care and contact arrangements involving their two children, a 15-year-old boy and a four-year-old girl. The teenage son has been living with his father since August 2025, while his mother exercises contact with him.
The parents share care of their daughter, alternating in blocks of two, two and three days.
The husband opposed the application, arguing that his estranged wife had based her maintenance claim on the incorrect assumption that both children lived with her full-time. He currently contributes R5,850 monthly towards the daughter’s expenses for the periods she stays with her mother and pays the son’s living expenses in full.
He also keeps his wife and both children on his medical aid. Husband disputes wife’s financial position. The woman’s business provides professional hair and make-up services, primarily for weddings, bridal bookings and other special events. She told the court that her income was irregular and seasonal, with deposits received for future bookings not necessarily representing money available for personal use.
She explained that the business had to retain funds to cover operational expenses, including stock, products, freelance artists, subcontractors, travel, equipment, refunds, suppliers, insurance and payments to assistants. She did not receive a fixed monthly salary but withdrew money from the business when funds were available to cover personal and household expenses.
Although she submitted business bank statements covering December 2025 to May 2026, she did not state under oath how much she earned on average each month.Her husband relied on the statements to argue that she received between R141,500 and R223,000 monthly.
He calculated that after business expenses, approximately R109,800 remained available to her each month. The bank statements also reflected that her business paid several personal expenses, including school fees, electricity, groceries, takeaways, clothing, fuel, insurance policies and two vehicle instalments.
Her spending included R47,344.79 on household necessities and R32,240 on her personal expenses.
Husband’s salary and monthly expenses
The husband submitted his payslips for June, July and August 2026, showing average gross monthly earnings of R54,598.68. His average net salary was R32,838.63, increasing to R35,574.63 when his bonus was included.
The judge noted that these figures included emergency overtime and standby allowances, meaning his income would be lower without these additional payments.
His monthly expenses included payments towards a personal loan, food, fuel, transport, electricity, clothing, medical aid-related costs and the children’s activities.
He also paid R3,066.47 monthly towards Vodacom contracts covering himself and his estranged wife. According to the court papers, his monthly expenses exceeded his income by just over R4,000.
Judge questions wife’s financial disclosure
In considering the application, Judge Thulare highlighted the purpose of Rule 43, which provides a speedy and inexpensive remedy for interim relief in divorce proceedings. The judge noted that the procedure was important in ensuring that both parties had a fair opportunity to present their cases and were not disadvantaged by unequal financial resources.
However, the judge was not persuaded that the woman had fully disclosed her financial position.
“I am not persuaded that the applicant took this court into her confidence and disclosed her true financial position, in particular her monthly income from her business,” the judge said.
The judge found that the husband’s response was not far-fetched, fictitious or clearly untenable, as he had provided factual evidence to challenge the woman’s claims.
Jugde Thulare said the court could not grant an order, which was not appealable, where the husband’s response raised genuine factual disputes supported by plausible evidence.
On the children’s care arrangements, the judge said the family advocate would investigate the matter and provide an expert report on care and contact. There was no reason to interfere with the existing arrangements in the absence of evidence of prejudice or circumstances showing that they were not in the children’s best interests.
The application was dismissed, with no order as to costs.— IOL.