HMETRO

RDC HUMILIATED IN US$2.50 COURT WAR

By Fidelis Munyoro

A SIX-YEAR legal battle over the equivalent of just US$2.50 has ended in another crushing defeat for Chikomba Rural District Council after the Labour Court ruled that the local authority must first obey previous court orders before pursuing fresh litigation.

The council has been locked in a bitter dispute with former employees Lawrence Magwiroto, Rosa Chikwama and Martha Mudzana, who were dismissed in September 2020 following disciplinary proceedings over alleged cash discrepancies.

Magwiroto’s case centred on a missing ZWL$50, worth about US$2.50 at the time.

However, what started as a minor workplace dispute has snowballed into a costly legal nightmare for the council, which has repeatedly found itself on the losing end of court rulings.

In the latest setback, Labour Court judge Justice Motion Jaravani upheld a preliminary objection raised by the former workers and ruled that the council cannot continue seeking relief from the courts while ignoring orders already issued against it.

“It is not for the litigants to choose which decision to comply with or to defy,” Justice Jaravani said.

The three workers successfully challenged their dismissals before the National Employment Council Exemptions Committee (ExCom), which in March 2021 ordered their reinstatement without loss of salaries or benefits.

Instead of complying, Chikomba RDC appealed the decisions to the Labour Court.

Those appeals were dismissed between February and October 2024, leaving the reinstatement orders intact.

Despite the defeats, the council still failed to reinstate the workers.

The former employees then pursued their unpaid salaries, benefits and other dues, resulting in an arbitral award covering the period from January 2019 to August 2025.

The council again appealed.

But the workers argued that the local authority had “dirty hands” because it remained in defiance of existing court orders.

Justice Jaravani agreed.

The court ruled that the reinstatement orders remained valid and enforceable and that the council could not simply ignore them because it disagreed with their implications.

In another blow for the local authority, the judge dismissed arguments that the reinstatement orders were not binding because they did not provide for damages instead of reinstatement.

According to the court, the council had opportunities to raise those issues during earlier appeals but failed to do so.

“The dirty hands rule prohibits courts from countenancing litigants’ defiance of the law by granting them audience despite their non\-compliance with the law,” the judgment stated.

The court also found that the council’s refusal to comply with the reinstatement orders amounted to an unfair labour practice under the Labour Act.

Justice Jaravani said the council must either reinstate the employees or follow legal procedures to prove that reinstatement is no longer possible and offer damages instead.

The court removed the council’s latest appeal from the roll until it complies with the outstanding reinstatement orders.

While the merits of the workers’ monetary claims were not determined, the ruling delivered another major victory for Magwiroto, Chikwama and Mudzana.

Leave a Comment