Elliot Ziwira-At The Bookstore
There are people who live to eat, others who eat to live, and still others who live off the sweat of their fellow human beings.
This is because food occupies a central place in the way human beings interact with one another and with their environment. It has the power to forge lasting relationships, just as it can destroy them and undermine social progress. Little wonder, then, that food has remained an important motif in literature.
Brian Chikwava’s timeless novel, “Harare North”, employs symbolism and literary motifs to expose human foibles and vices that militate against personal regeneration and social progress.
As poverty, disillusionment and frustration grip individuals, they increasingly resort to escapist tendencies in search of relief. The narrator and several other characters seek escape through food, the toilet, the chestnut tree, sex, drugs and alcohol.
Like Oscar Wilde in “The Importance of Being Earnest”, Chikwava is conscious of the obsessive nature of human appetites and the unreasonable behaviour that emerges when individuals take their indulgences to dizzying heights. What should ordinarily provide comfort and sustenance becomes an instrument of self-destruction.
The use of symbolic elements, particularly food as an elixir from an otherwise burdensome existence, aggravates, instead of alleviating the characters’ predicament. Contrary to offering genuine relief, these indulgences become alternative forms of obsession, breeding irrationality and destructive behaviour.
The narrator in “Harare North” is acutely aware of the conflicts that erupt over food. He observes:
“Food is a tricky subject; things get funny over it. Even before Shingi loses his graft, food sometimes make conversation funny. And that’s not with me but also Aleck, Tsitsi and Farayi. But that’s not big surprise to me. Or even Shingi.
“The two of us have had chance of witnessing them troubles that food can cause from long time…The problem is that disagreement over food always end up with innocent people hurt. Food arguments don’t fail to have victim”.
Indeed, many families have been torn apart by disagreements over food or the relentless struggle to put it on the table. Those caught up in such conflicts, whether as providers or consumers, often emerge alienated, embittered and emotionally wounded. In the process, new gods are fashioned out of material needs and appetites, demanding unquestioning allegiance.
Carl Jung (1964) aptly captures this predicament: “Contemporary man is blind to the fact that, with all his rationality and efficiency, he is possessed by ‘powers’ that are beyond his control.
“His gods and demons have not disappeared at all; they have merely got new names. They keep him on the run with restlessness, vague apprehensions, psychological complications, an insatiable need for pills, alcohol, tobacco, food – and, above all, a large array of neuroses,” (Jung, 1964:82).
Thus, food, like alcohol, sex and drugs, and even seeking to relieve oneself, becomes another manifestation of neurosis—an obsession bordering on madness. The food crisis drives individuals to abandon their obligations, familial ties and cultural values. Food is elevated from a basic human necessity into an object of worship, another god demanding sacrifice.
Among Africans, food is traditionally associated with hospitality, solidarity and the establishment of strong social bonds (Hove, 2002). Yet, in “Harare North”, the obsession with food undermines the very social cohesion it should promote.
Sekai, for instance, is particularly anxious about food when it comes to her husband’s relatives. As the narrator reveals, she is regarded as mean because of her constant complaints about the alleged disappearance of food whenever he is around.
However, ironically, food is central to her relationship with her friends and lover, Yakov, with whom it is consumed in abundance. The contradiction exposes the selective nature of generosity when appetite and personal interests take precedence over familial obligations.
Aleck, too, is perpetually preoccupied with food. He frequently admonishes those around him about the need to moderate their consumption, thus, alienating himself from others. The narrator, on the other hand, is an unabashed glutton who relishes food, but is reluctant to buy it.
He appears to live for eating, with little else inspiring him. Food becomes both a perceived solution to his problems and a problem in its own right. He even admits to giving himself permission to consume all the food Aleck buys, a habit that also compromises their relationship.
His obsession also drives him to scheme against Shingi and Tsitsi’s relationship. Blind to his own shortcomings, the narrator regards Tsitsi as parasitical since she eats without working. Food equally complicates his relationships with Paul and Sekai, while becoming a bone of contention in the exchanges between Tsitsi and Aleck.
The anti-hero’s obsession takes an even more disturbing turn when he destroys the floor of the squat that shelters him while frantically hunting a rat he suspects of invading his food store, or ‘granary’. Thus, his irrational attachment to food compounds his already precarious existence, pushing him further into the abyss.
Food is also implicated in Shingi’s psychological, physical and emotional destruction in the mental streets of their existence. Instead of buying food, the characters become increasingly obsessed with obtaining it for free. Taking their cue from Dave and Jenny, who survive on expired tinned food sourced from the backstreets, Shingi engages in violent confrontations with vagabonds in the mental streets in pursuit of free food for himself and the indolent narrator.
Sadly, his lack of physical resilience proves inadequate against the brawn, hardened disposition and relentless survival instincts of the inhabitants of these streets of death — the death dealers. Therefore, food, as a manifestation of neurosis (Jung, 1964), is effectively deified, with tragic consequences in “Harare North”.
Relationships are compromised, hope is stifled and progress is scuttled in the pursuit of culinary gratification.
The destructive consequences of neurotic obsession with material gratification are also explored in Ruby Magosvongwe’s “Name Any Price”, published in “Hunting in Foreign Lands and Other Stories” (2010). Here, the impact of material obsession on familial, communal and national relationships is examined from an equally compelling perspective.
The stress is not so much on the consumption of food as on the relentless desire to provide it and acquire material wealth. This obsession manifests itself in the rush for gold in the Diaspora, where individualism and materialism threaten the foundations of social life.
Like many husbands whose wives have migrated in search of economic opportunities, Tomuonga finds himself caught between overwhelming sexual desire and the pressure to maintain appearances in an increasingly materialistic society.
His fixation on photographs of his beautiful wife, Blessing, which he ‘smooches’ in moments of derangement until he becomes sexually aroused, is symptomatic of the vanity and emotional deprivation associated with relationships sustained across vast geographical distances.
His subsequent rape of their maid, Danai, in an attempt to satisfy his sexual desires is a grave violation that cannot be excused by his circumstances. Nevertheless, his conduct also exposes the deeper social and moral decay that the story interrogates. The abuse of a vulnerable domestic helper, in particular, reveals the unequal power relations that allow the privileged to exploit those beneath them.
Thus, the familial fabric is torn apart. Tomuonga’s predicament is more than a personal tragedy. It is also symptomatic of a wider social malaise. Marriages cannot be sustained by material provisions alone, especially when partners are separated by thousands of kilometres. Money, photographs and letters cannot substitute for physical intimacy, emotional companionship and the responsibilities that underpin conjugal relationships.
Tomuonga’s escape from justice through corruption is as corrosive as the materialism that drives migration and leaves families fractured. As a senior civil servant, his conduct exposes the extent to which society can degenerate when the pursuit of wealth is allowed to determine the administration of justice.
When senior government officials, senior police officers, judges, attorneys, prosecutors and magistrates become compromised by corruption, justice itself is undermined, with potentially devastating consequences for social stability.
In the race for material gain, there are no real winners except money. Individuals, families, groups, communities and nations all stand to lose. Tomuonga loses $13 million in Zimbabwean currency, a considerable sum at the time. His wife, Blessing, loses the fruits of her labour in the Diaspora; Danai loses everything in a system where justice is rendered a farce.
Her family, too, suffers under the weight of fear, intimidation and the desperate need to keep body and soul together. In the end, familial relationships are shattered, all for a fleeting moment of sexual gratification.
Indeed, the price humanity sometimes pays for the pursuit of sustenance and material gratification is too high to contemplate. Whether through the obsessive consumption of food in Brian Chikwava’s “Harare North” or the destructive pursuit of wealth in Ruby Magosvongwe’s “Name Any Price”, the consequences are strikingly similar. Human beings become prisoners of their appetites, relationships are sacrificed, justice is compromised and the prospects of collective progress are diminished.
• For an immersive reading experience, visit the DigiHub Retail Shop at Herald House, corner George Silundika Avenue and Sam Nujoma Street in Harare. Contact Leon on 0772739306.