SUNDAYMAIL

Chikomba council’s baffling six-year legal battle over ZiG50

IN the grand theatre of Zimbabwean litigation, the Chikomba Rural District Council (RDC) has achieved something truly remarkable.

It has turned a dispute over ZiG50 — roughly the price of two sadza-and-beef specials at the time — into a six-year legal saga and more courtroom defeats. At the centre of this epic are three former employees — Lawrence Magwiroto, Rosa Chikwama and Martha Mudzana — who were dismissed in September 2020 over alleged cash discrepancies.

The council’s evidence? A claimed prejudice of ZiG50. That is about US$2.50. Even by the standards of petty cash, that is petty cash.

The three refused to go quietly, took their case to the National Employment Council Exemptions Committee and won. The council was ordered to reinstate them without loss of salaries and benefits. Simple, right?

Well, it proved to be not that simple. Instead of reinstating the trio, the Chikomba RDC did what any self-respecting stubborn institution would do: It appealed. And appealed. And appealed again. Between February and October 2024, its absurd appeals were dismissed with obscene regularity. But here is the plot twist: The council still did not reinstate them.

One might admire the audacity if it weren’t so expensive. The three former employees then pursued outstanding salaries, benefits and union dues, securing an arbitral award covering January 2019 to August 2025.

The council bizarrely appealed again.

This time, the employees came armed with a legal doctrine so delicious it should be served with custard: the dirty hands doctrine.

In plain English: “Why should the court hear you when you have been ignoring its orders for years?”

Justice Motion Jaravani — a man clearly unimpressed by the council’s approach to compliance — agreed. The court found the council’s failure to comply with reinstatement orders constituted an unfair labour practice.

It noted, with the patience of a teacher explaining long division for the fifth time, that the council could have challenged the decisions on grounds of damages during its previous appeals — but did not.

The dirty hands rule, the judgment explained, “prohibits courts from countenancing litigants’ defiance of the law by granting them audience despite their non-compliance with the law”. In other words: Wash your hands before you come to court. The court removed the council’s appeal from the roll pending compliance with the reinstatement orders. Each party bears its own costs. Six years later, three former employees are still fighting for justice, and the Chikomba RDC is still being told to go back and do what the courts ordered.

Somewhere, a ZiG50 note is gathering dust, wondering how it brought down a local authority’s entire legal strategy. Moral of the story: If a court tells you to reinstate three employees over US$2.50, maybe — just maybe — it is cheaper to just do it.

Leave a Comment