Fidelis Munyoro
Chief Court Reporter
A BID by Bindura miner Temba Hlongwane to reclaim his position as managing director of Side Electrical (Pvt) Ltd, trading as Botha Gold Mine, has suffered a setback after the High Court struck his application for reinstatement off the urgent roll.
Justice Samuel Deme ruled that Hlongwane and Augustine Manyau, who was ousted as chairperson of the mine’s board at the same time Hlongwane lost his post, had failed to demonstrate exceptional circumstances or irreparable prejudice warranting preferential treatment through urgent court proceedings.
The two had approached the court seeking to reverse their removal from the company’s management structures following a disputed extraordinary general meeting held on October 20.
They wanted the court to suspend the implementation of resolutions passed at the meeting, restore Hlongwane as managing director and reinstate Manyau as board chairman pending the determination of two separate legal proceedings.
However, the mine’s directors opposed the application, arguing that the applicants had failed to establish urgency after waiting 14 days from the time they were ousted before approaching the court.
They maintained that the two were aware of their removal on October 20 but had not acted with the urgency required by the rules of the court.
They also challenged Hlongwane’s reliance on an alleged letter barring him from company operations, which was not attached to the application.
Representing the two, Advocate Tafadzwa Mapuranga argued that they had approached the court within 11 court days of the disputed meeting, maintaining that the delay was not inordinate and had been adequately explained.
He further argued that the consequences of the disputed resolutions went beyond the loss of positions, describing the developments as a corporate governance crisis that effectively amounted to a “board coup”.
However, opposing counsel Advocate Givemore Madzoka dismissed the urgency argument, arguing that the applicants had participated in the meeting and even sought a revote after an initial ballot had been conducted in Hlongwane’s absence.
He also submitted that loss of employment was compensable and could not, on its own, justify urgent court proceedings.
In dismissing the application from the urgent roll, Justice Deme found that the alleged prejudice did not warrant immediate judicial intervention.
“The consequences which are to affect the applicants cannot be characterised as matters requiring urgent attention of the court,” he ruled.
The judge was also unconvinced by Manyau’s argument that his removal as board chairman justified urgent intervention, noting that the position could be restored if the substantive proceedings were decided in his favour.
“The contemplated prejudice is easily reversible,” Justice Deme said.
The court also questioned the applicants’ failure to attach the alleged barring letter, which formed a central part of Hlongwane’s argument that he had subsequently been excluded from company operations.
Justice Deme emphasised the responsibility of legal practitioners to independently assess applications before certifying them as urgent, citing guidance from the Supreme Court.
The ruling does not determine the legality of the applicants’ removal from the company’s management structures. It only disposes of their attempt to secure immediate relief through the urgent roll, leaving the substantive corporate dispute to be determined through the ordinary court process.