HERALD

When bizarre defence exposed a miscarriage of justice

Fidelis Munyoro

Chief Court Reporter

WHEN Ashly Paruma stood before a magistrate accused of assaulting his mother, his defence took an extraordinary turn.

He accused his mother of involvement in international marijuana trafficking, claimed she wanted to sacrifice him in a cult and alleged that she had tried to make him drink what he described as “red poison”.

He told the court he had uncovered the alleged plot because he was a pharmacist.

The claims appeared disconnected from the assault charge he was facing. But a High Court judge who later reviewed the proceedings should have raised a far more important question: Was the accused mentally responsible for his actions when the alleged offence occurred?

That question was never answered.

Instead, Paruma (26) was convicted of physically abusing his mother, Chipo Ngairongwe (45), and fined US$400 or four months in prison if he failed to pay.

The conviction has since come under scrutiny, with High Court judge Justice Lucy-Anne Mungwari finding that the magistrate overlooked warning signs of a possible mental disorder and failed to obtain medical evidence addressing the accused’s mental state at the time of the alleged assault.

The judge concluded that the failure went to the heart of the proceedings and resulted in a miscarriage of justice.

“I am satisfied that a real and substantial miscarriage of justice has occurred and as a result the proceedings cannot be certified as being in accordance with real and substantial justice,” she ruled.

The case highlights an important distinction in criminal justice: being mentally fit to stand trial does not necessarily mean that an accused person was criminally responsible when an alleged offence was committed.

It also raises questions about how courts handle accused persons whose behaviour and testimony suggest possible mental health complications.

The case that raised questions

The case arose from an incident at the family home on July 7, 2026.

Paruma had allegedly returned late and demanded that the gate be unlocked. His mother told the trial court that he then attacked her, striking her with clenched fists, pulling her by the hair and removing part of her weave.

She also reported injuries to two fingers, pain in her back and swelling on her face.

However, when Paruma presented his defence, the proceedings took an unexpected direction.

He accused his mother of being involved in international marijuana trafficking and claimed she wanted to sacrifice him in a cult because he had refused to join her business.

He further alleged that she had attempted to make him drink “red poison”, claiming his knowledge as a pharmacist had enabled him to detect the alleged plot.

Justice Mungwari said these statements should not simply have been dismissed as an attempt to discredit the complainant.

“These assertions are disconnected from the charge. They are grandiose and persecutory in character, and none of them was supported by any evidence,” she said.

The judge said the nature of the allegations should have prompted the magistrate to consider whether they could be manifestations of a disordered mind.

The warning signs

The concerns were not confined to Paruma’s courtroom testimony.

On July 29, 2026, the State raised the issue of his mental condition, informing the magistrate that he was experiencing hallucinations.

The prosecutor also told the court that Paruma’s mother had reported similar episodes in the past and that the State was uncertain about his mental condition when the alleged assault occurred.

The magistrate subsequently ordered an examination by two doctors under section 26 of the Mental Health Act.

The doctors later certified Paruma fit to stand trial.

However, their findings did not resolve the question that had become central to the case.

One doctor recorded a history of substance abuse, while the other noted pressured speech and grandiosity, but concluded that Paruma was fit to stand trial while receiving treatment.

Neither provided an opinion on his mental state on July 7, when he allegedly assaulted his mother.

Justice Mungwari found that the magistrate had also improperly invoked section 26 of the Mental Health Act because Paruma had already been arraigned, pleaded not guilty and commenced his trial. The charge carried a possible prison term of up to 10 years.

The judge emphasised that the medical assessments had answered a different question from the one that needed to be resolved.

“The former asks whether the accused is fit to be tried. The latter asks whether he was criminally responsible when he acted,” she said.

In other words, determining whether someone can understand court proceedings and participate in their defence is different from establishing whether a mental disorder affected their criminal responsibility at the time of an alleged offence.

Justice Mungwari said the magistrate should have ensured that psychiatric evidence specifically addressing Paruma’s mental state at the time of the alleged assault was obtained and presented before the trial was concluded.

Without that evidence, a critical issue remained unresolved.

A second failure: delayed court records

The High Court review also exposed shortcomings in the administrative handling of the case.

The magistrate initially failed to provide all the documents required by the reviewing judge, including Paruma’s medical reports and an affidavit from a medical practitioner detailing the injuries sustained by his mother.

The outstanding documents only reached the High Court on October 7, three weeks after the deadline set by the judge.

Justice Mungwari warned that delays in responding to review queries could have serious consequences, particularly where an accused person remained exposed to a sentence arising from an irregular conviction.

“Magistrates are reminded that prompt review responses are necessary because an accused may lose his liberty while an irregular conviction remains operative,” she said.

The delay also complicated the remedy available to the High Court.

Paruma’s US$400 fine had fallen due on September 28, meaning he could already have paid it or served the alternative four-month prison term by the time the complete record reached the reviewing judge.

Justice Mungwari said a retrial would have been ordered had the record been submitted on time.

However, given the delay and the possibility that Paruma had already served the sentence or paid the fine, she found that ordering a fresh trial at that stage would prejudice him.

She, therefore, withheld certification that the proceedings were in accordance with real and substantial justice.

A lesson for the courts

Beyond the fate of one accused person, the judgment carries an important reminder about the handling of criminal cases involving possible mental health conditions.

The courts must establish whether an accused person is fit to participate in proceedings, but they must also address criminal responsibility where evidence raises doubts about the person’s mental state when an alleged offence occurred.

Leave a Comment