HERALD

Why social contracts must apply to both halves of society

Alice Tagwira-Beyond Boundaries

In the quiet drawing rooms, bustling kitchens, and corporate boardrooms of contemporary Zimbabwe, an unspoken social contract has long governed interactions between the sexes.

It is a framework where domestic labour, emotional goodwill, and social accommodation are frequently treated as an immutable baseline for women, regardless of the ideological climate those women are forced to navigate.

However, a quiet, intellectually rigorous conversation is beginning to ripple across urban centres from Harare to Mutare.

It is not a call for radical disruption or legislative overreach, but rather a profound re-examination of social economics: the principle that respect, access, and care are not infinite resources to be squandered on those who actively disparage them.

To understand this shift, one must first examine how societies traditionally regulate behaviour.

Anthropologically and sociologically, human communities have always relied on collective consequences to maintain social cohesion.

Historically, patriarchal structures have wielded this tool with clinical precision.

Sociological literature has long documented how informal sanctions shape public behaviour. Studies in gender socialisation reveal that societies maintain conformity through deeply ingrained mechanisms of approval and disapproval.

For generations, women who deviated from expected norms—whether by being overly outspoken, fiercely independent, or challenging traditional hierarchies—frequently encountered subtle and overt social punishments. These ranged from social exclusion and gossip to the withdrawal of institutional and familial support.

Society rarely batted an eyelid at these consequences; they were treated as the natural, self-policing mechanisms of a traditional order.

Yet, a curious asymmetry has persisted.

While structural and social penalties have historically been deployed to police women’s autonomy, misogyny and casual chauvinism have often enjoyed a profound immunity from social cost.

As the British philosopher John Stuart Mill observed in The Subjection of Women, systems of inequality persist not merely through legal coercion, but because they are lubricated by daily, unexamined social habits.

When contempt for a demographic carries zero social friction, that contempt becomes cost-free.

And behaviour that incurs no cost is endlessly repeated.

Consider a common domestic scenario, familiar across many middle-class households. A husband invites a colleague or lifelong friend over for dinner. Over the course of the evening, this guest treats the gathering to a litany of casual microaggressions: jokes mocking female intelligence, assertions that women belong exclusively in domestic silos, or sweeping generalisations regarding female incompetence.

Under the traditional script, the female host is expected to smile through the discomfort, carve the roast, pour the wine, and extend flawless, warm hospitality. She must absorb the devaluing rhetoric with what novelist Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie might term “performative grace.”

The question facing modern social commentators is simple, logical, and deeply unsettling to the status quo: Why?

Why should access to a woman’s labour, culinary skill, emotional intelligence, and social goodwill be treated as an unalienable human right, even when directed toward someone who views her demographic as fundamentally inferior?

This is where the argument transcends mere grievance and enters the realm of rational boundaries.

Refusing to extend voluntary, unpaid domestic labour to a guest who openly denigrates women is not an act of aggression; it is an exercise in economic and social coherence. It is the simple recognition that access to a home’s hospitality is contingent upon basic civility.

When asked why a plate was not set, the response requires neither theatre nor vitriol. A calm, matter-of-fact statement—“I do not extend special hospitality to people who openly disrespect women”—suffices. It reframes the interaction from a personal quarrel to a structural consequence.

This recalibration cannot stop at individual front doors; it requires a collective awakening among women themselves.

Too often, patriarchal conditioning runs so deep that women find themselves laughing along with misogynistic jokes told by brothers, bosses, or husbands to keep the peace.

They defend acquaintances who routinely demean women, prioritising personal familiarity over principle. By doing so, they inadvertently subsidise the very attitudes that limit their freedom.

Data from gender research organisations consistently highlights that systemic inequality thrives in environments where victims and bystanders are socialised to accommodate their own marginalisation.

When women collectively decide to stop smoothing over the rough edges of misogyny—when they cease offering the social rewards of attention, laughter, domestic service, and unquestioning loyalty to those who hold them in contempt—the incentive structure changes.

Critics may prematurely label this as vindictive or unnecessarily divisive.

Yet, diplomacy does not require self-abnegation.

True social maturity involves aligning one’s resources with one’s values.

Zimbabwean society is evolving rapidly, navigating the delicate intersection of rich cultural heritage and modern democratic ideals.

Vision 2030 and our broader national development goals emphasise inclusivity, human dignity, and the full participation of all citizens in national building. Economic and social progress cannot be fully realised while one half of the population is expected to intellectually and domestically service the prejudices of the other.

This is an invitation to consistency.

If a man chooses a public or private persona rooted in the disparagement of women, he must be allowed to experience the natural social gravity of that choice.

Distance, disapproval, and the withdrawal of unearned goodwill are not acts of cruelty; they are the baseline mechanics of a self-respecting society.

Respect cannot remain a one-way street where women are mandated to offer endless patience and grace, while receiving casual contempt in return.

By introducing meaningful social consequences to misogyny, society can finally foster an environment where mutual respect is not just preached from podiums, but practiced across every dinner table in the land

Leave a Comment