HERALD

Court rejects businessman’s bid to vary US$488k divorce deal

Fidelis Munyoro

Chief Court Reporter

A WEALTHY businessman’s plea for more time to settle his AUD 700 000 (US$488 000) divorce settlement has hit a judicial brick wall, with the High Court ruling that financial hardship cannot simply be asserted; it must be proved.

Shahid Siddiqui’s bid to rewrite a divorce settlement worth AUD 700 000 has been rejected by the High Court after Justice Fatima Maxwell found that he had failed to demonstrate a material change in his financial circumstances to justify altering the payment terms he had voluntarily accepted.

In a judgment delivered after hearings early this month, the court dismissed an application by Mr Siddiqui to vary a consent paper incorporated into his divorce order on June 7, 2024, in a dispute involving his former wife, Marina Pamela Siddiqui, nee Young.

At the heart of the battle was an agreement under which Siddiqui undertook to pay his former wife AUD 700 000 in full and final settlement of her proprietary claims following the dissolution of their marriage.

Siddiqui told the court that he had paid AUD 342 519 (US$238 000) towards the obligation, but was struggling to meet the next instalment, which fell due on June 7, 2026. He sought permission to clear the outstanding balance through monthly payments of AUD 15 000 until the debt was extinguished.

He argued that his financial circumstances had deteriorated, particularly as his business, Property World (Pvt) Ltd, was performing worse than when the settlement was negotiated. He maintained that the proposed arrangement was realistic and would allow him to honour his obligations without suffering severe financial prejudice.

His position was that he had made genuine efforts to pay, pointing to consistent monthly payments of AUD 15 000 (US$10 000) since March 2026. He also disputed his former wife’s accusation that he had unilaterally altered the court order, insisting that the interim payments were subject to the outcome of his application.

But Ms Young mounted a challenge, accusing Siddiqui of approaching the court with “dirty hands” after falling into arrears on the second instalment. She argued that he was already in default by AUD 138 334 (US$96 000) and had effectively granted himself the relief he was asking the court to authorise. She further contended that the proposed monthly arrangement would yield AUD 180 000 annually, below the agreed annual instalment of AUD 183 344.

Ms Young also questioned the reliability and completeness of his financial disclosures. The management accounts submitted covered only five months, she argued, despite Mr Siddiqui having had 12 months to raise the instalment. She further questioned whether Property World was his sole source of income and pointed out that the consent paper identified seven private companies in which he retained shares.

For Justice Maxwell, the decisive weakness was not the existence of financial pressure, but the failure to prove how circumstances had changed since the agreement was signed.

“The change was not demonstrated by numbers,” the judge observed, emphasising that Mr Siddiqui had not provided comparative financial records showing the position of his business when the settlement was negotiated and how it had subsequently deteriorated.

The judge was equally troubled by the absence of an explanation concerning the other companies in which Siddiqui held shares, finding that his silence on their significance to his financial standing counted against him. Invoking the principle that variation requires good cause, Justice Maxwell stressed that regret over a bargain is not enough to undo it. “Regret without good cause is not enough,” the judge declared.

Leave a Comment